But the new trek could easily reverse that result if they find something for anton yelchins chekov to do. In 2007, tv broadcaster cbs had the series special effects remastered. He turned both into action adventure movies and boiled any individuality out of them. Many fans may have assumed that the differences between star trek in. What is the difference between the different star trek series. The new star trek movie opening in theaters may 8 is the first remake of the classic 1966 version. Deep space nine is star treks best world, because its the. One of the main differences between star trek and star wars is that star trek is a science fiction drama whereas star wars is a science fiction fantasy.
This idea has upset many fans who feel that it has made the series less original and turned. Star wars, originally a trilogy, is a space opera fantasy franchise set in the dis. Within nine months of initial publication, the book was reprinted five times. It can be a little difficult to compare the three different corners of the franchise. Also in slate, matthew yglesias ranks every star trek movie, television. In light of the release of the first trailer for the upcoming star wars movie, the force awakens, i thought it apropos to revisit an old controversy between the star wars and star trek franchises.
The film is based upon the characters created for the original 1960s star trek series and makes multiple references to events established in that series as well as the original series of theatrical features particularly star trek ii. Star wars is completely fictional, while roddenberry used actual scientific facts and ideas to base star trek around. A closer look at the new uss enterprise from star trek. The alternate timeline being the one of star trek 2009. However, tas had topend writers, most of which were serious tos veterans. The next generation had the advantage of being created. Eventually, though, they settle their differences, after which the overall tone becomes more reminiscent of the original series. On the left side you can see the effects from the original 1967 version of the episode, on the. The two shows were quite different in tone, structureand quality. From the oversaturated colors and procedural storytelling of the original series through the awkward highdefinition digitallyshot prequel enterprise, things changed a lot. With studios being more greeneyed and focused on the billion dollar kickback, they want star trek to replicate the success of its resurgent rival. What are the differences between the various star trek series.
Generations, a film that actually included some of the original series cast, but was still ultimately a tng movie. The original series for the first time thank you, netflix, and i see that klingons used to look like this. Star trek was introduced as a liveaction television series in 1966 that lasted three years. The differences between television series and movies answers. Adding to chris answer, tas the animated series from the 1970s gets left out when talking about the various series. The animated series commenced in 1973 based directly on the original series but lasted only two seasons with a combined total of 22 episodes. This nicely lays out how the two timelines are related, and shows they both continue to exist. Discovery promises a very unique take on the trek universe. Jul 17, 2017 one of star trek discovery showrunners is finally breaking his silence regarding the shows changes to the klingons. Difference between star trek and star wars difference. May 15, 20 star trek ii reprised the original series best villain, and the lightcomedy timetravel caper star trek iv showed that the franchises signature political concerns could be updated for the. Sep 14, 2019 star trek is an iconic movie franchise.
Theres a humanity, for the lack of a better word, that was taken away from them. Truthfully, the debate is substantiated, but at this point, it is a little old. Star trek vs star wars difference and comparison diffen. In 1994, the next generation crew would take over the film franchise with star trek. I realize that costume design probably came a long way in the approximate 25 years between production of the 2 series, but even so, the physiological difference is enormous. Star trek, originally a tv series, is a space western science fiction that centers around a crew who serves in starfleet, a spacebased peacekeeping and humanitarian armada. Weird differences between the first star wars movie and its. The further adventures of the crew of the uss enterprise. Star wars, originally a trilogy, is a space opera fantasy franchise set in the distant past of a fictional galaxy, revolving around princes, princesses, knighthood, and chivalry. The basic differences are that star wars is suppose to take place in the past and of course a galaxy far, far away. With the subsequent publication of novels, comics, animated series, toys and feature films, star trek grew into a popular media franchise. Both fans and participants of the series are twominded about this version.
It was retitled star trek 1 after subsequent volumes in the series were published. With vic mignogna, todd haberkorn, christopher doohan, grant imahara. The new star trek movie series have struggled to find its footing, though they still put butts in seats. What is the difference between star trek and star wars. Star wars and star trek are both science fiction series.
May 18, 2011 in 2007, tv broadcaster cbs had the series special effects remastered. Originally star trek was about issues that humanity encountered in space, issues that needed to be thought through ra. Jul 22, 2017 the new star trek movie series have struggled to find its footing, though they still put butts in seats. Whats the difference between star trek and star wars. What are the differences between mountain and trek bikes. In addition, the makers of the game star trek online, which takes place in the original timeline, released this image which helps clarify where their game fits into the new status quo. The essential difference between star wars and star trek. Dutton, april 1977, along with star trek 4 and star trek 9. Star trek has been around for over 50 years, resulting in multiple television series which look and feel very different from todays television.
Similarities between star wars and star trek 1090 words 5 pages. It is interesting to note that both were made available as films. Jul 28, 2017 fuller later left the show, citing scheduling differences between star trek. The differences between sequels, reboots and spinoffs. The original series and the release of the motion picture. The motion picture would have plenty of time to work out all the kinks but alas, as the movies dismal tomatometer and decades of fan gags about the motionless picture can attest, all of treks time off didnt translate into an auspicious bigscreen debut for the crew of the.
Nov 15, 2014 this video shows the differences between the 2 versions of the classic star trek episode i, mudd. Enterprise, originally titled enterprise, is a prequel to the original star trek series. For over 40 years now, fans of both star trek and star wars have been arguing about which movie franchise is better. The themes and differences of star wars and star trek bartleby. The classic star trek crew edges out the new star trek crew by a score of 431. Star trek is the adventures a group of starfleet crew faces when travelling in space. However, the film does not directly tie into the events of any previous star. From the the original series to the next generation, all the way to the reboot movies, the franchise has pushed scifi forward. Lets take a look at the new actors who will be stepping up into these classic roles. The series introduces many of the different alien species important to the star trek universe, such as the vulcans and klingons. Imdb in 2007, tv broadcaster cbs had the series special effects remastered. Difference between star trek and star wars compare the. Star trek timeline explained, including two kirks, two different.
Obviously, both shows are excellent and fundamental. Star trek 2009 is connected to the prime star trek universe by the event that carried both nero and spock prime to their early alpha quadrant. Early glimpses of the series have shown that discovery is not going to be shy about visually reinventing the venerable science fiction franchise, with the drastic redesign of the klingons being perhaps the most notable and controversial example of this. Today we bring you a closer look at the uss enterprise from the movie, including a surprising details you may have missed. Star trek and star wars are not the same as some people think. Its a vision defined by cooperation, multiculturalism and scientism being challenged by a rabid cur seeking to spark a war with the federation to end. Beyond was the first film in the series since star trek. This video shows the differences between the 2 versions of the classic star trek episode i, mudd. Alex kurtzman spoke with cnet about the borg in star trek.
Admittedly, the time travel mechanic isnt without its faults and wasnt to everyones taste, but it. Physiological changes in klingons between star trek tos and. Jan 24, 20 weird differences between the first star wars movie and its preceding novelization. Abrams rebooted the film series in 2009, he was eager to. One of star trek discovery showrunners is finally breaking his silence regarding the shows changes to the klingons. A closer look at the new uss enterprise from star trek into. But there are decided differences between the two universes both in terms of look, style and equipment differences. Tos it was a pioneering series, with so many firsts black woman on tv that wasnt a maid or a housekeeper, americans and russians working together, and a really strong cadre of writers. In star trek 2009, did the original timeline survive. The original series vs the next generation vs the reboot. Trekmovie continues our deep dive of analysis into star trek into darkness. Well, one of the main differences that have been said is that start trek is a science fiction and star war is a science fantasy. What is the difference between the different star trek.
Star treks hope went awol with trump hollywood in toto. What is the difference between star trek and star wars movies. Every star trek movie ranked from worst to best trek. When star trek fans fight about the best trek show, nine times out of 10 theyre arguing about the original series versus the next generation. Even in its day, better effects would have been possible, if it werent for the lack of the neccessary funding. Tng had some great moments, bit it came with annoying characters troi and wesley, some real stinkers of episodes, and a series of subpar movies. Star trek i mudd visual effects comparison youtube. A gap of 10 years passed between the broadcast of the last episode of star trek. The main differences between the two series are some added functionality as well as design changes. Comparing the star trek reboot movies to the next generation. What are the differences between the various star trek. List of star trek films and television series wikipedia.
Find out just how different it will be from the great series that came before. Its television series and films have been part of several generations of audiences, each bringing. Every star trek movie ranked from worst to best jul 20, 2016 with a full decade between it and the end of the original series, you might think 1979s star trek. Feb 23, 2016 adding to chris answer, tas the animated series from the 1970s gets left out when talking about the various series. Khan, a genetically engineered superhuman from the past, who grappled with kirk long ago in the tv episode space seed, and was marooned by him on what was at the time a lovely little garden planet, is accidentally discovered on what is now a desert hellscape by chekov, whos searching for a dead planet on which to test a. Star trek is officially a fivedecade old franchise. Tos was also shot and edited on film, giving another visual difference between it and the other shows. Star trek ii reprised the original series best villain, and the lightcomedy timetravel caper star trek iv showed that the franchises signature political concerns could be updated for the. To understand what went wrong for star trek movies over the past decade, its important to understand why abrams 2009 effort worked so well. The contents of the book were later incorporated into the star trek reader ii e. How does the 2009 star trek film mesh with enterprise canon.
425 528 1390 403 741 1210 490 870 1463 433 1163 481 1516 911 769 223 669 787 620 276 1495 1487 720 106 789 76 303 414 356 1000 555 392 261 1064 262 218 1104 1332 1249 1347